 |
|
| On
the move: Electrical engineering CAD provides support |
| published
in: CAD/CAM,
edition no. 1/2000 |
There
is a continuing high demand for rationalisation in plant and mechanical
engineering. The example of Lödige
Fördertechnik GmbH
based in Warburg/ Scherfede demonstrates the potential for substantial savings
in the field of electrical engineering design.This company supplies high-tech
materials handling technology to the global market.
Lödige
has evolved from a small-scale producer of hydraulic lifting platforms to a
global player with a workforce of nearly 800. Decades of expertise in the field
of high-end materials handling technology form the basis of the company's
success and continuous growth. Today, Lödige
is a leading supplier of solutions for all tasks which involve moving
something."We get things moving", is the basis of the corporate
philosophy at Lödige.
Originally dedicated to the lifting platform business, the company has since
diversified into a number of areas:
• Elevator systems for passengers and freight
• Production logistics
• Air freight systems and aircraft maintenance equipment.
They are also involved in the development and execution of special projects. For
example, Lödige
are also well-known in the motor car industry, havingdeveloped one of the
world's most advanced presses for BMW in Regensburg. The press itself originates
from the mechanical engineering firm Müller-Weingarten, whilst the materials
handling technology was supplied by Lödige.
"Something like this is supplied as a complete system", explains
engineer Burkhard Pöhler, responsible for electrical design at Lödige
- i.e. including the materials handling technology, the complete control system,
the essential visualization technology, and the corresponding camera and
scanning systemsmen.
The
ultimate air freight terminal
Lödige
are particularly proud of a key project for British Airways at London's Heathrow
Airport which is about to commence operation. This is the ultimate cargo centre.
The cargo building, with a length of more than 300 metres, a depth of 100 metres
and a height of 40 metres, has a handling area of around 83,000 square meters on
four storeys, and is designed to accommodate some 800,000 tonnes of air freight.
There are plans to expand capacity to 1.2 million tonnes during the course of
the year. British Airways invested over DM 1 billion in the current
structure.The bulk of the materials handling technology, accounting for around
DM 350 million in total, was supplied by Lödige.
Over 100 automatic vehicles for the transportation and handling of aircraft
containers and wire boxes, together with 50 elevators, 85 lifting systems and
around 10,000 storage cells for wire boxes, were installed by the materials
handling technology experts Lödige.
This complex materials handlings technology is controlled by an extremely
powerful computer control system. Lödige
already have extensive expertise in the field of air freight technology.
Large installations for KLM in Amsterdam, Singapore Airlines in Singapore and
Swissair in Zürich bear testimony to the fact that Lödige
is one of the world's leading experts in the field of complex air freight
terminals.
Nevertheless, the
British Airways project posed a particular challenge, not just because of the
comparatively tight deadlines, but also due to its sheer scale and the
additional requirements imposed by the customer. Virtually all the fork-lift
trucks were replaced with a newly developed system called "Skyfork".
40 of these new Skyforks are used in the new cargo terminal in London. These
manoeuvrable machines were purpose-designed by the company CEO, Dr. Rudolf Lödige,
and have of course been patented.
British
Airways also stipulated that the installation should have a comparatively long
service life of 50 years, more than a nuclear power station. Other unusual
requirements included circuit diagrams in A1 or A2 format, a complicated
labelling system for operating equipment, and adaptation of the circuit diagram
documents into British Airways' existing documentation system. "We were
soon forced to realise", explains Burkhard Pöhler, "that our computer
support system, which we had been using for around six years, was not up to the
job. Because we are also suppliers to the automobile industry, and
car manufacturers generally dictate which CAD software must be used by their
suppliers, we were already using EPLAN
5. In other words, we already had some well-established programs
which worked well, but when it came to this major project, they revealed a
number of weaknesses. Following my research at CeBIT last year, I finally
decided on EPLAN 21
from EPLAN Software & Service GmbH & Co. KG as the most suitable
system.In retrospect, I can say that without EPLAN
21, we would not have been able to accomplish many of the tasks in
this major project within the allotted time and with the desired quality."
Modern software - better circuit diagrams
The introduction of a
brand new system such as EPLAN
21 will in itself produce better circuit diagrams. Troubleshooting
became easier. All data was available online without the need for complex update
procedures. The unusual circuit diagram formats for the Heathrow project were no
problem for EPLAN 21.
"Although circuit diagrams can be drawn in A1 or A2 format with other
systems, evaluation is sometimes only possible up to A3 format", explains
Burkhard Pöhler. "Furthermore, in addition to a very complex
numbering system, British Airways also wanted various logos and extensive
document flags on the plans. For this project, we were unable to design a
standard circuit diagram to DIN complete with installation, location ID and
standard numbering. The device tag alone consists of 6 different components.
Because many of the parameters in EPLAN
can be set and altered, we were able to adapt to the requirements of our
customer".
The
ten designers and engineers who work with EPLAN
21 in the electrical design department at Lödige were
confronted with a number of problems initially, due to the special requests
imposed by British Airways. "With EPLAN
21, there were a number of things which had been conceived as
functions by EPLAN Software & Service, but which did not always work exactly
as we had wanted. EPLAN Software & Service responded very quickly to our
criticisms. An expert from EPLAN Software & Service came to our premises and
resolved some of the problems on site, and the software itself was adapted very
quickly.In retrospect, I do not believe that any comparable programs on the
market would have been capable of supporting the complexities of this major
project as effectively as EPLAN
21, partly as a result of our suggestions", enthuses
Burkhard Pöhler. For
example, up to six designers were working simultaneously at times on the cargo
centre project, who generated some 50 different types of circuit diagrams for
switch cabinets. With parts lists, I/0 overviews, terminal and wiring lists, the
plans can soon run to 8,000 pages.
With eight twin licences for EPLAN
5 and EPLAN 21,
the company feels that it is well-equipped to handle the forthcoming tasks.
Centrally administered via a dongle, an NT server distributes the licences, thus
facilitating access from any sufficiently powerful computer in the design
department. This eliminates the need for individual licences for each designer.
Lödige will retain its links to the cargo centre, because it has signed a
maintenance contract for the next few years. "This was another good reason
for us to switch to a modern, powerful electrical CAD system.And as I have said,
the system is still open to expansion. In five or ten years' time, it will be
joined by new technology – hopefully supplied by us", explains Burkhard Pöhler.
Automatic
editing in all related documents
The editing service
offered by EPLAN 21
is consistent. For example, if a certain component in the circuit diagram is
replaced, or a device tag changes, these amendments can be made automatically at
the push of a button in all corresponding documents and appendices, without the
need for time-consuming evaluation procedures.
EPLAN 21 includes
an ASCII generator which supports the rapid external transfer of data. Lödige
can easily generate a full parts list including all installation, location and
device tags, if required. A materials handling system like the British Airways
cargo centre contains over one hundred thousand installed
electrical components. A situation arose when a manufacturer was forced to
recall a certain type of sensor. Thanks to EPLAN
21, it was possible to generate a list showing 900 of these
components with their precise position in the overall system.Furthermore, this
project uses some 150 PLCs, all of which are interlinked. There is also an
extensive visualisation system showing every status in the system, despite
having over 30,000 sensors and switches.
One particularly clever feature of the materials handling technology in this
cargo terminal is the option of operating the system from the control desk in
remote control mode.If an error occurs – e.g. a container is askew – the
operator can rectify this from the control desk using a joystick. The joystick
allows him to move every vehicle, every materials handling belt, and every motor.
"This is essential", explains Burkhard Pöhler, "because the
distances in this enormous building are so vast that it would take an operator
up to 15 minutes to get to the scene of the problem. It is also important to
remember that the vehicles used here travel at 160 m/min, and access to them is
protected accordingly". In 90 % of cases, remote control operation is
sufficient to rectify the fault.For the remaining 10 % of problems, the operator
must physically go to the scene.
Hence, it is not difficult to see that a project of this kind contains an
enormous amount of electrical engineering development work. In some cases,
external staff had to be drafted in.According to Burkhard Pöhler, this worked
extraordinarily well:"This was another factor in favour of EPLAN
21, because EPLAN
21 is a 100% Windows-compatible program. Anyone who is familiar with
Word or Excel will soon get to grips with EPLAN
21 after a short period of training."
Tapping
new rationalisation potential
EPLAN
21 also enabled the company to tap into another potential area of
rationalisation. A wire-cutting machine cuts wires to length, automatically fits
them with wire end ferrules or insulates them, and labels the wires continuously
with their connection points in the switch cabinet. This machine saves up to 30
% assembly time in switch cabinets.Using an ASCII interface configured at Lödige,
the machine receives the corresponding wire lists from EPLAN
21. The wire lengths are then calculated by a separate software
package.In future, Burkhard Pöhler also hopes that EPLAN
21 will help him to get to grips with another common problem –
"getting the designers to work to a common denominator. If ten different
designers are given the task of designing a switch cabinet, you will get ten
different circuit diagrams, even if you prescribe certain requirements such as
customer specifications or in-house standards.In this respect, I am confident
that EPLAN 21,
with its administration and hierarchy functions, will provide even greater
support in future. As project manager, I prepare a circuit diagram template
showing the correct procedures for the circuit diagrams, controls, buses etc.
and which components and cables etc. may be used. This original data is
then given to the designer with the necessary rights to the EPLAN
21 design software in order to prepare the final circuit diagram. EPLAN
5 only supports this approach to a limited extent, because each user
can access the parts they require at that particular moment, whereas EPLAN
21 can be arranged hierarchically. "Admittedly, this method of
working is not always popular amongst designers, because they are keen to
utilise their creative freedom. However, particularly in the area of electrical
engineering, it can be extremely problematic if too many different circuit
diagrams exist.
Burkhard Pöhler wishes to stress one very important point:"I actually envy
mechanical engineers. They receive a large number of drawings and data on CD-ROM
with corresponding DXF files from their component or assembly suppliers, and are
able to position these directly in their drawings.I am constantly asking for
similar support from our component suppliers. Some attempts have been
made.Phoenix, for example, collaborates with EPLAN Software & Service and
generates macros which I can then transfer into my draft circuit diagram. But
even here, there is a great deal of catching up to do. Due to the very short
product cycles, all key parts, components and assemblies should be available to
users with the relevant documentation at any time from the Internet".
Electrical engineering is at the heart of machinery production. According to
Burkhard Pöhler, electrical engineering now accounts for 30 % of the total
product creation chain, and the trend is rising. Circuit diagrams in particular
are playing an ever more pivotal role. They must be absolutely precise and
contain all the necessary information. "In future, powerful modern computer
support, such as that offered by EPLAN
21, will be absolutely indispensable", summarizes Burkhard Pöhler.
Global competition continues to escalate, and working with the very latest tools
is the only way to keep pace and remain competitive.
Last edited: 2002-07-16 14:46
|